Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

THE MEATBALL SHOP CLASSIC SAUCE COLLECTION

We opened The Meatball Shop in 2010 with the goal of serving delicious food, made with wholesome ingredients, at a fair price. With that same commitment to high-quality, fresh ingredients, we’re proud to bring you some of our favorite sauces.

From our kitchen to yours, enjoy.

a person preparing food in a kitchen

OUR STORY

Since The Meatball Shop opened in NYC in 2010, our Classic Tomato Sauce has been our most popular. 

The Classic is vegan and non-gmo verified. We keep it simple with a high-quality, eight-ingredient recipe. 

Now when you can't get to The Meatball Shop, you can bring a little bit of The Shop into your home

It's the exact same sauce we serve in our Shops!

No surprise, the best results come from using the best ingredients...

The sauce starts with “sweating” of onions (cooking them slowly, until translucent but not brown, to extract as much flavor as possible), and the flavor continues to build from a nice, long, low-heat simmering after the tomatoes are added.

Our Story
a close up of a bottle

OUR PRODUCTS

Our classic TOMATO SAUCE

We keep it simple with a high-quality recipe. Just California whole peeled tomatoes, fresh onions, olive oil, salt, garlic, oregano, bay leaves and red pepper. Fresh and classic. Vegan.

Our CLASSIC TOMATO BASIL

We keep it simple with a high quality recipe. Just California whole peeled tomatoes, fresh onions, salt and red pepper. . .  with an extra kick of fresh basil and herbs. 

Our CREAMY TOMATO BASIL

This rich and creamy tomato sauce with California whole peeled tomatoes, fresh basil, herbs and Parmesan cheese makes the perfect partner to fresh pasta and some crusty bread. Fresh and classic.

Our spicy-ish ARRABBIATA

Our Classic Tomato Sauce with a kick. Whole California peeled tomatoes, fresh onions, garlic and herbs, made spicy-ish with dried red pepper flakes sautéed in olive oil. Classic kicked up a notch.

Our Sicilian PIZZA SAUCE

We keep it simple with a high quality recipe. We took our classic tomato sauce, cooked our tomatoes a bit longer and added the perfect amount of oregano and herbs. Best. Pizza Sauce. Period.

Buy Online